Skip to main content

Old Mine Cut Diamond 5 Carat

to
58
865
322
779
513
339
248
205
122
93
75
73
73
71
65
44
22
21
21
21
19
15
9
8
8
7
7
5
5
3
3
2
2
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
17
10
7
3
3
Sort By
GIA Certifed 5 Carat Old Mine Cut Engagement Platinum Ring
Located in Chicago, IL
5 Carat GIA-Certified Old Mine Cut Diamond Ring A 5 carat old mine cut diamond, especially one
Category

2010s American Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond Flower Brooch
Located in Chicago, IL
gold (front – silver, back – gold). It is centered with an old mine cut diamond (6.4 x 6.3 mm
Category

Antique 1880s Victorian Brooches

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Silver

Art Deco Diamond Ring, 900 Platinum Old Mine Cut 5 3/4 Genuine .71 Carat
Located in Greensboro, NC
its strength and enduring beauty. The center of the ring showcases an Old Mine Cut diamond solitaire
Category

Vintage 1920s Unknown Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Victorian Old Mine Cut Diamond and 18 Carat Gold Cluster Ring
Located in Chipping Campden, GB
This stunning cluster ring holds old mine cut diamonds set within the platinum setting. The central
Category

Antique 1880s British Victorian Cluster Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold

Vintage Art Deco 1.19 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
Located in Montgomery, AL
Accented by the following gemstones 1 - 6.6mm X 4.48mm Old Mine Cut Diamond; J Color; SI1 Clarity
Category

Early 20th Century Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

White Diamond, Blue Sapphire, Gold, 18k Gold, White Gold

.82 Carat Old Mine Brilliant Cut Diamond Gold Art Deco Engagement Ring
Located in Stamford, CT
Art Deco 1930s Old Mine brilliant cut diamond gold engagement ring. This exquisite piece is a
Category

Early 20th Century Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, White Gold, Gold

Antique 4.12 Ct Old Mine Cut Diamond Pearl Earrings
Located in Chicago, IL
very sparkly old mine cut diamonds (G-H-I color, VS1-VS2 average clarity). The diamonds are accented by
Category

Vintage 1910s Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Pearl, Gold, 14k Gold, Silver

GIA 2.50 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
Located in New York, NY
Made of platinum, this ring centers a sparkling GIA certified old mine cut diamond that weighs
Category

20th Century Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Emilio Jewelry Gia Certified 38.85 Carat Old Mine Diamond Necklace
By Emilio!
Located in New York, NY
mine cut Gia certified diamond in this necklace layout. Each diamond is Gia Certified. Allow Emilio
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Choker Necklaces

Materials

Diamond

Peter Suchy 1.82 Carat Old Mine Diamond Platinum Engagement Ring
By Peter Suchy
Located in Stamford, CT
7 dazzling old mind cut diamonds with an approximate total carat weight of 1.82cts. This vintage
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Antique 7 Ct Old Mine Cut Diamond Flower Brooch 1880s
Located in Chicago, IL
gold (front – silver, back – gold). It is centered with an old mine cut diamond (6.4 x 6.3 mm
Category

Antique 1880s Victorian Brooches

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Silver

0.88 Old Mine Cut Diamond and Platinum Solitaire Style Ring
Located in Montgomery, AL
diamond in the center. Old Mine cut diamonds are often times similar to the modern cushion cut diamond
Category

Vintage 1920s Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

White Diamond, Platinum

Antique 5 Stone 3 Carat Ultra Fine Old Mine Cut Diamonds 18k Gold Enamel Ring
Located in Miami, FL
Antique 5 Stone 3 Carat Ultra Fine Old Mine Cut Diamonds 18k Gold Enamel Ring Description: Just
Category

Vintage 1920s Art Nouveau Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, Enamel

Art Deco 3.16 Carats Old Mine Cut Diamond Ruby Arrow Platinum Engagement Ring
Located in Philadelphia, PA
Centering an old mine cut diamond weighing 2.22 carats total - E color with SI1 clarity. Bezel set
Category

Vintage 1930s Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Ruby, Platinum

1.36 Carat Old Mine Brilliant Cut Diamond Platinum Engagement Ring
Located in New York, NY
accentuated by dazzling baguette cut diamond accents. The ring is size 5 1/4, and can be resized. Inventory
Category

Early 20th Century Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Vintage GIA 1.01 carat old mine cut diamond 18k white gold engagement ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
old mine cut diamond, graded K color and SI2 clarity. The distinctive faceting and soft, cushion-like
Category

Vintage 1980s Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, White Gold

Art Deco GIA 1.26 Carat & 1.01 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond Toi et Moi Ring
Located in Los Angeles, CA
.  One of the Old Mine Cut diamonds weighs 1.26 carats, GIA certified K color/VS2 clarity. The other Old
Category

Vintage 1920s Unknown Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Blue Sapphire, Platinum

Victorian GIA 1.00 carat old mine cut diamond 14k rose gold engagement ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
mine cut diamond, graded L color and SI1 clarity. Set in warm 14k rose gold, the softly rounded facets
Category

Early 20th Century Victorian Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 14k Gold, Rose Gold

Art Deco Old Mine Cut Diamond Platinum Tulip Vintage Engagement Ring
Located in Philadelphia, PA
Centering an old mine cut diamond weighing approximately 0.30 carat - I color with SI2 clarity
Category

Vintage 1930s Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Old Mine Cut Diamond 18 Carat and Platinum Marquise Shape Cluster Ring, c1910
Located in London, GB
adorned with a striking cluster of graduating old mine cut diamonds, totalling to approximately 2.20ct
Category

Vintage 1910s English Edwardian Cluster Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold, Platinum

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond and Emerald Ring, circa 1920
Located in London, GB
Old mine diamond and emerald ring. Set with one central cushion shape old mine diamond in an open
Category

Vintage 1920s Unknown Edwardian Cluster Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Platinum

2.20 Carat Total Vintage Old Mine Cut Diamond Bar Brooch in Platinum, E-F / VVS
Located in Scottsdale, AZ
delicate, elongated design adorned with dazzling old mine-cut diamonds, each meticulously set to enhance
Category

20th Century Unknown Contemporary Brooches

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Victorian 18K Gold Elongated Cluster Old Mine Cut Diamond Ring
Located in Venice, CA
This spectacular Old Mine Cut diamond ring presents a wide band of encrusted diamond sparkle
Category

Antique Late 19th Century Unknown Victorian Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold

Art Deco 1.71 CTW Old Mine Cut Diamond Platinum Ribbon Engagement Ring
Located in Philadelphia, PA
Centering an old mine cut diamond weighing approximately 1.03 carats total - I color with SI2
Category

Vintage 1930s Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Peter Suchy EGL 1.35 Carat Old Mine Round Diamond Platinum Engagement Ring
By Peter Suchy
Located in Stamford, CT
Diamond engagement ring. EGL certified round old mine cut center diamond with 2 round brilliant cut
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

EGL Certified 2.05 Carat Old Mine Diamond Platinum Art Deco Engagement Ring
Located in Stamford, CT
glamour and charm. 1 old mine cut diamond, I SI approx. 2.05cts EGL Certificate # 400167155D 6 single cut
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

3.88 Carat Total Three-Stone Old Mine Cut Diamond Elongated 14 Karat Gold Ring
Located in Scottsdale, AZ
absolutely radiates on the finger and fills it with sparkle from end to end. It features three Old Mine cut
Category

Antique 19th Century Unknown Contemporary Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 14k Gold, Yellow Gold

Old Mine Cut Diamond Bar Brooch, 1.75 Carats in 14K Gold and Sterling Silver Lv
Located in Austin, TX
around 1875, ten old mine cut diamonds sit in individual silver crowns, each with their own unique hand
Category

Antique Late 19th Century American Victorian Brooches

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold, Yellow Gold, Sterling Silver

Necklace and pendant with old mine cut diamonds up to 0.40ct platinum
Located in The Hague, ZH
long by 4.9 mm wide total weight: 6.2 grams set with: - 5 x 1.3 mm – 3.6 mm old mine cut diamond
Category

1990s Dutch Modern Pendant Necklaces

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

14K White Gold Old European Cut and Old Mine Cut Diamond Flower Ring
Located in Venice, CA
, and 0.9 of a carat. The eight Old Mine Cut diamonds range in size from 3 - 3.5 mm, and have a combined
Category

Vintage 1910s Unknown Edwardian Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 14k Gold, White Gold

Victorian 18K Old Mine Cut Flower Dangle Earrings
Located in Venice, CA
These delicately crafted 18k gold Victorian earrings feature Old Mine Cut diamonds carefully prong
Category

Antique 1880s Unknown Victorian Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

Antique Inspired 6.06 Carat Old Mine Diamond 18K Yellow Gold Earrings
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
Center Stone: 42 Diamonds Cut: Old Mine Cut Weight: 6.06 Carats Color: I-J Clarity: SI Metal: 18K
Category

20th Century Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

Vintage 1.50 carat old mine diamond 18k yellow gold spray ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
This vintage 18k yellow gold spray ring features an approximately 1.50-carat old mine cut diamond
Category

Vintage 1970s Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Pink Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

Natural Old Mine Diamond Ring 14K Gold
By Estate Jewelry
Located in East Brunswick, NJ
natural old mine cut Diamonds are very clean VS2 clarity and H color totaling .50 carat. The top of the
Category

Mid-20th Century Cluster Rings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold, White Gold, Yellow Gold

EGL Certified 2.61 Carat Old Mine Diamond Yellow Gold Bezel Set Stud Earrings
Located in Stamford, CT
Cut Diamond Approx. Total Weight 1.46 carats L-M, SI2 EGL Cert. US400120263D 1 Old Mine Cut Diamond
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

Stunning 1.28 Carat Old Mine Cushion Cut Diamond Platinum Engagement Ring
Located in New York, NY
This magnificent platinum engagement ring is centered with a sparkling old mine cushion cut diamond
Category

Early 20th Century Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Sapphire, Platinum

1820 European 18k gold, turquoise, old mine cut diamond & natural pearl bracelet
Located in London, GB
pearls and approximately 4-5 carats of old mine cut diamonds. It is a remarkably beautiful piece and is a
Category

Antique 1820s European Neoclassical Cuff Bracelets

Materials

Diamond, Natural Pearl, Turquoise, 18k Gold

Tahitian Pearl Old Mine cut Diamond Earrings 14K White Gold Art Deco
By Estate Jewelry
Located in East Brunswick, NJ
Tahitian Pearl Old Mine cut Diamond Earrings 14K White Gold Art Deco This absolutely stunning pair
Category

Mid-20th Century Art Deco Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Pearl, 14k Gold, White Gold

Tiffany & Co. 2.5 Carat Old Mine Diamond Platinum Brooch Pin 1900 Antique
By Tiffany & Co.
Located in New York, NY
approximately 2.5 Carats of magnificent Old Mine Cut Tiffany Diamonds set in Platinum in an open work scroll and
Category

Early 20th Century American Edwardian Brooches

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Antique Victorian 18k Gold Old Mine Cut Diamond Black Enamel Cluster Pin Brooch
Located in Montclair, NJ
Genuine Diamonds - Cushion & Round Old Mine Cut - Buttercup Prong Set - J/L Color - VS2/SI2 Clarity
Category

Antique Early 1900s Victorian Brooches

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, Enamel

Victorian Old Mine Cut Diamond 14K Yellow Gold Silver Antique Engagement Ring
Located in Philadelphia, PA
Centering an old mine cut diamond weighing approximately 1.15 carats O/P color with I1 clarity and
Category

Antique 1860s Victorian Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 14k Gold, Yellow Gold, Silver

Antique 19th Century Old Mine Cut Diamond Crescent Moon Star Brooch Yellow Gold
Located in Lisbon, PT
-set throughout with 31 Old Mine-cut diamonds totaling approximately 3.8 carats, all stones in open
Category

Antique Mid-19th Century Unknown Victorian Brooches

Materials

Diamond, Gold, Yellow Gold

Platinum Old Mine Diamond Pendant Necklace Antique Victorian Edwardian
Located in New York, NY
. DIAMONDS Central Diamond Old Mine Cut - a sparkling white white jewel of great beauty Approximately 1/5
Category

Antique Late 19th Century Unknown Edwardian Pendant Necklaces

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Victorian 2.11 CT Old Mine Cut Diamond 14 Karat Gold Antique Engagement Ring GIA
Located in Philadelphia, PA
Centering an old mine cut diamond weighing 2.11 carat - G color with SI1 clarity Set in an eight
Category

Antique 1880s Victorian Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 14k Gold, Yellow Gold

RETRO Brooch with ruby verneuille and old mine cut diamond up to 0.08ct 18k gold
Located in The Hague, ZH
RETRO 18k bicolour brooch set with ruby ​​and old mine cut diamond up to 0.08ct – G/H – SI
Category

Vintage 1950s Dutch Retro Brooches

Materials

Diamond, Ruby, 18k Gold

Vintage Old Mine Cut Diamond and Filigree Stick Pin in Yellow Gold and Platinum
Located in Scottsdale, AZ
, meticulously adorned with Old Mine cut diamonds that sparkle with a unique charm and brilliance, evoking the
Category

Early 20th Century Unknown Edwardian Brooches

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 10k Gold, Yellow Gold, Platinum

Vintage Art Deco 0.23ct OLD Mine Cushion Cut Diamond Engagement Ring Palladium
Located in New York, NY
or Promise ring with estimated 0.17ctT OLD MINE CUSHION Center diamond in G-H color, SI clarity
Category

Vintage 1930s Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Palladium

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond And Ruby Gold Ring
Located in Cairo, EG
Antique 14k yellow gold ring with 5 old mine cut diamonds and 5 natural pigioun blood rubies color
Category

Vintage 1910s Cluster Rings

Platinum Diamond Art Deco Ring - Mine Cut .30ctw Vintage Milgrain Filigree
Located in Greensboro, NC
- 1930s Metal Content: Platinum Stone Information Natural Diamond Carat(s): .20ct Cut: Mine Color: I
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Antique French Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Bangle Braclete
Located in Cairo, EG
Antique french 14k white gold old cut diamond cuff bracelete with estimate weight of 5 carats H
Category

Antique 1890s Cuff Bracelets

Edwardian Inspired Old Mine Diamond 18K Yellow Gold Cluster Earrings
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
Center Stone: 50 Diamonds Cut: Old Mine Cut Weight: Approximately 5 Carats Color: J Clarity: SI
Category

Vintage 1920s Edwardian Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, White Gold, Yellow Gold

Antique 9K Yellow Gold Pearl and Old Mine Diamond Cluster Ring
Located in Braintree, GB
: Material: 9K Yellow Gold Gemstones: Diamond: Central old mine-cut, approximately 0.60 carats Clarity: SI1
Category

Antique 1870s European Cluster Rings

Materials

Diamond, Pearl, Yellow Gold

Victorian opal old mine cut diamond 18k yellow gold cluster ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
Size: Approximately .50 carat Accent stone: 10 old mine cut diamonds Weight: Approximately 2.10 carats
Category

Early 20th Century Victorian Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, Opal, Gold, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

40 Carat Old Mine Colombian Drop Emerald & Baguette Diamond 18K Gold Necklace
By Gad & Co.
Located in Miami, FL
Diamonds, 5-3.5mm each - 25 Tapered Baguette Cut Diamonds, 1.5mm each Old Mine Emeralds are commonly
Category

20th Century Colombian Art Deco Drop Necklaces

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Emerald, 18k Gold, Gold, White Gold

Antique Emerald And Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Dangling Earrings
Located in Cairo, EG
weight of 5 carats and old cut diamond weight of 2.5 carats H color vs clearity total earrings length
Category

Vintage 1910s Dangle Earrings

Art Deco Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring .18ct Old Mine 18K Antique Original
Located in Dearborn, MI
Man-Made) 100% Natural .18 Carat Diamond Weight Shape: Old Mine Cut Color: I (Near Colorless
Category

Vintage 1920s Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, White Gold

Edwardian 14K Gold Platinum 6ctw Old Mine Diamond Snow Flake Pin Brooch Pendant
Located in Montclair, NJ
--Stone(s):-- (25) Natural Genuine Diamonds - Chunky Cushion Old Mine Cut - Prong Set - VS2-I2
Category

Vintage 1910s Edwardian Brooches

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold, Platinum

Peter Suchy EGL Certified .79 Carat Old Mine Diamond White Gold Engagement Ring
By Peter Suchy
Located in Stamford, CT
Old mine diamond engagement ring. The diamond at the center of this piece is a .79ct old mine
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 14k Gold, White Gold

Victorian Ceylon Sapphire & Old Mine Cut Diamond Halo Ring in 14 Karat Yellow Go
Located in Boston, MA
mine-cut diamonds. These diamonds, totaling 0.64 carats, are graded H color and VS2 clarity, adding a
Category

Antique 1880s Victorian Fashion Rings

Materials

Diamond, Sapphire, 14k Gold, Yellow Gold, Platinum

2.97 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Platinum Art Deco Cluster Cocktail Ring
Located in Stamford, CT
, single cut, old mine cut and old European cut diamonds, totaling 1.65cts. 2 straight baguette diamonds
Category

Mid-20th Century Cluster Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

  • 1
  • ...
Get Updated with New Arrivals
Save "Old Mine Cut Diamond 5 Carat", and we’ll notify you when there are new listings in this category.

Old Mine Cut Diamond 5 Carat For Sale on 1stDibs

Find the exact old mine cut diamond 5 carat you’re shopping for in the variety available on 1stDibs. Every item for sale was constructed with extraordinary care, often using Gold, Platinum and 18k Gold. You can easily find a 469 antique edition and 176 modern creations to choose from as well. Making the right choice when shopping for an old mine cut diamond 5 carat may mean carefully reviewing examples of this item dating from different eras — you can find an early iteration of this piece from the 18th Century and a newer version made as recently as the 21st Century, both of which have proven very popular over the years. Creating an old mine cut diamond 5 carat has been a part of the legacy of many jewelers, but those produced by Mark Broumand, Single Stone and Hancocks are consistently popular. Today, if you’re looking for an old mine cut version of this piece and are unable to find the perfect match, our selection also includes cushion cut and round cut alternatives. Most of our old mine cut diamond 5 carat for sale are for women, but there are 174 pieces available to browse for men.

How Much is an Old Mine Cut Diamond 5 Carat?

The price for an old mine cut diamond 5 carat starts at $560 and tops out at $1,091,830 with these rings, on average, selling for $9,782.

The Legacy of Diamond in Jewelry Design

Antique diamond rings, diamond tiaras and dazzling vintage diamond earrings are on the wish lists of every lover of fine jewelry. And diamonds and diamond jewelry are primarily associated with storybook engagements and red-carpet grand entrances — indeed, this ultra-cherished gemstone has a dramatic history on its hands.

From “A Diamond Is Forever” to “Diamonds Are a Girl’s Best Friend,” pop culture has ingrained in our minds that diamonds are the most desired, the most lasting and the most valuable gemstone. But what makes the diamond so special? Each stone — whether it’s rubies, sapphires or another stone — is unique and important in its own right. April babies might claim diamonds for themselves, but just about everyone wants this kind of sparkle in their lives!

There are several factors that set diamonds apart from other stones, and these points are important to our gem education.

Diamonds are minerals. They are made up of almost entirely of carbon (carbon comprises 99.95 percent; the remainder consists of various trace elements). Diamonds are the hardest gemstones, ranking number 10 on the Mohs Hardness Scale. Even its name, diamond, is rooted in the Greek adamas, or unconquerable. The only object that can scratch a diamond is another diamond. Diamonds are formed deep within the earth at very high temperatures (1,652–2,372 degrees Fahrenheit at depths between 90 and 120 miles beneath the earth’s surface) and are carried up by volcanic activity. Diamonds are quite rare, according to the Gemological Institute of America, and only 30 percent of all the diamonds mined in the world are gem quality.

In the 1950s, the Gemological Institute of America developed the 4Cs grading system to classify diamonds: clarity, color, cut and carat weight. Not all diamonds are created equal (there are diamonds, and then there are diamonds). The value of the diamond depends on the clarity (flawless diamonds are very rare but a diamond's value decreases if there are many blemishes or inclusions), color (the less color the higher the grade), cut (how the diamond’s facets catch the light, certain cuts of diamonds show off the stone better than others) and carat weight (the bigger, the better).

When you start shopping for a diamond engagement ring, always prioritize the cut, which plays the largest role in the diamond's beauty (taking the time to clean your diamond ring at least every six months or so plays a role in maintaining said beauty). And on 1stDibs, a range of buying guides can be found for those in the market for antique engagement ringsvintage engagement rings or Art Deco engagement rings

Shop antique and vintage diamond rings, diamond necklaces and other extraordinary diamond jewelry on 1stDibs.  

Questions About Old Mine Cut Diamond 5 Carat
  • 1stDibs ExpertApril 5, 2022
    Mine cut diamonds are up to 300 years ago. Mine cut diamonds were popular around the 18th century during Victorian times and are still in high demand today. You’ll find a wide selection of mine cut diamond jewelry on 1stDibs.
  • 1stDibs ExpertFebruary 22, 2021
    Because the old mine cut is no longer used on diamonds, diamonds with this cut are rare and so you can often get quite a lot of money for them. Nevertheless, it is still dependent on the quality of the individual diamonds and on the color, clarity, cut and carat number.
  • 1stDibs ExpertFebruary 22, 2021
    Old mine cut diamonds are usually worth less than old european cut diamonds. Because they are generally 10-15% less expensive, they are often larger than other cut diamonds for engagement rings.
  • Like any other diamond, an old mine cut diamond's worth depends on a variety of factors. These factors include the 4C's (color, clarity, cut, carat), the overall beauty and "make" of the stone, the demand, supply, etc. On average however, old mine cuts are typically priced slightly lower (around 5-10%) than modern cut diamonds.